Tuesday, October 29, 2024

La Semaine Dernière A Mes Yeux




(26 octobre --- 02 novembre)

Cliquez pour voir/cacher
Ma Semaine Gastronomique
Date Petit déjeuner Déjeuner Dîner Snacks,Sucreries,Boissons et Fritures
26 Riz,Lait Riz,Ruhi,Luffa Riz,Ruhi Nouilles
27 Riz,Ruhi,Luffa Riz,Thankuni(ombelle asiatique),Petit poisson Riz,Thankuni(ombelle asiatique),Reba carp ---
28 Khichuri,Œuf,Ruhi Riz,Petit taro chinois Riz,Petit taro chinois Halwa du semoule
29 Khichuri,Œuf Riz,Poulet Pain,Poulet Biscuit
29 Khichuri,Œuf Riz,Poulet Pain,Poulet Biscuit
30 Khichuri,Œuf Riz,Petit taro chinois Riz,Petit taro chinois ---
01 Khichuri,Œuf Riz,Petit poisson Pain,Lait Biscuit

Review Decision On Tariff And Vandalism

Review the decision on tariff and criminal act,
For more revenue and justice perfect.

Three weeks ago government lowered the prices of sugar and edible oil. Yet the two items are still being sold at higher prices. In general, 52% taxes( 30% duty,15% VAT and 7% advanced tax) were imposed on sugar before the new directive took effect. On the other hand, 15% VAT along with other duties were imposed on edible oil. Govt halved the import duty on sugar and halved the VAT on edible oil. Along with onion, import duty on edible oil and sugar constitutes a great part of import revenue. Slashing the duties will evidently lower the revenue generated from these two kitchen commodities.

In 2023, govt's sugar import stood at Tk 12710 crore. Every year govt imports Tk 25000 crore worth of edible oil. Now with the former duty structure, sugar alone generated Tk 6609.2 crore and edible oil Tk 3750 crore as import revenue. With the new tariff structure, revenue loss from sugar and edible oil will become Tk 1906.5 crore and Tk 1250 crore respectively. The decision would cost the govt altogether Tk 3156.5 crore in this time of austerity1&2.

As understood from desperation of tackling the inflation,the measures are pretty much in line with govt's top priority. At this time of slow business activity, revenue generation will be lower. This year govt faces an uphill task of meeting revenue target of Tk 5.41 trillion. Last year, revenue shortfall was Tk 381.57 billion against the target of Tk 4.1 trillion. The slow pace of revenue generation ( caused by political uncertainty, lack of capacity and slow business activity) is likely to hamper meeting the target. We have to wait for 1 or 2 months to see whether the tariff reduction has any impact on inflation.

My personal opinion is to review the decision immediately. Because sugar and to some extent edible oil get less priority in the list of essential kitchen items. So govt could easily retain Tk 3165.5 crore by reinstating the tariff structure. I am optimistic after the November 5 election things will improve dramatically including inflation.

Apart from fixing the revenue generation, addressing political uncertainty calls for objective stance on vandalism. Vandalism does not have different meanings for different people. It will be biased move for the govt to call one unlawful act vandalism while sparing the other one. Attacks on key public installation, foreign cultural institute, museum, police station, houses of former ruling party members should be treated as acts of vandalism and law should take its own course. Otherwise, biased justice will open another chapter of political agitation. In Sri Lanka, interim govt tried the attackers of presidential palace and the court sentenced them for their conduct. To gain the confidence of people from all walks of life, interim govt should do the same and immediately bring to book all the troublemakers, plunderers and arsonists. It is indeed a good news that United Nations Commission for Human Rights opened an office in Bangladesh. An independent forensic lab under the UN could help the probe on the atrocities committed during July and August. Reviewing the decisions taken so far could improve our revenue generation and help the govt gaining more confidence.

References:

  1. "Chinir Shulko 30% Theke Kome 15% Kora Hoechhey:NBR(Tariff On Sugar Lowered To 15% From 30%:NBR)",Daily Prothom Alo,October 09,2024.
  2. "Soyabin O Pam Tele Vat Chhar Diyecchey Sarker(Govt Slashed VAT On Soybean And Palm Oil)",Daily Prothom Alo,October 17,2024.

Thursday, October 24, 2024

Address Political Uncertainty

Consensus to address political uncertainty
May send a signal of greater clarity.

Central bank once again raised the policy rate by 50 basis points, making it 10% in a desperate measure to curb inflation. Governor earlier in an interview hinted to raise it even one more time in the coming weeks. Meanwhile, IMF downgrades Bangladesh's growth projection to 4% and anticipates that inflation will be around 10% next year. Earlier, the World Bank had downgraded the growth rate. Since inflation shows no sign of coming down, contractionary monetary policy will be prolonged.

The political protest,sit-in continue unabated. If the political crisis prolongs, it will create new problem as well as cast shadow over the economy. Unlike Sri Lanka where political parties formed the interim govt (which had support of even the outgoing regime) in a consensus, here the former ruling regime is nearly decimated,its student wing is facing ban and other parties are in no mood to have a dialogue with the former ruling regime before its trial. Some key groups associated with former regime signal to wind up their businesses. In addition, govt freezes bank accounts of many groups and owners who have been accused of corruption and money laundering activities. In the absence of greater political reconciliation, budget deficit may continue in the future. Many are demanding an election date. A specific date of the next election will clear away half of the uncertainty. Investors, businessmen and in general the economy will get a signal when the stalemate will be over. Maybe by mid November or by the end of November the draft reform policies and the white paper on corruption will be made public. This will further dispel the ambiguities on the objective of this govt. If this political uncertainty persists or lack of confidence on govt exists ,it will create new problems along with the ongoing economic woes.

Incumbent govt has a new responsibility in addition to fix the economy and start some reform programs. It is to clear political uncertainty arising from this regime change.

If it announces a date,even if it is 5/7 years later, or go for people's mandate for duration of the govt,which I propagated earlier in one of my pieces, it will give tremendous confidence to the economy and people. Because both will know where the country is heading and when it will be over.

When we are in the middle of an economic crisis, all the stakeholders (people,administration,parties) of this country have to think again whether our troubled economy and innocent people can bear the cost of frequent political misadventures.

Lack of reconciliation, rule of law and people's participation almost jeopardize bipartisan political structure, which somehow gives a kind of stability in many countries,in our country. Former ruling regime tried to do the "unnayan" (development) for people without taking their consent. By the same token, we see that "songsker" (reform) is being pursued for people bypassing their mandate. Trapping into the narrative of "biplobi sarker"(revolutionary govt) may cost the incumbent govt. Boasting such argument may invite another unsettling event that we should all try to avoid. People's mandate may throw cold water into all kinds of debate surrounding this govt. And it will be good for the economy. At the end of the day both " unnayan" and " songsker" will be done for the people. So they should be at the center stage of everything. Otherwise, I apprehend, vested quarters may exploit the situation as they did during the tenure of previous regime and during the caretaker govt. Our economy and taxpayers may not bear the cost of wrong policy decisions.

China recently lowers its policy rate. Earlier it had appreciated its currency. Low Chinese policy rate paves the path for cheap Chinese credit for the private sector. While foreign currency keeps coming, a large trade deficit in the bilateral trade calls for taking Chinese credit for the private sector to pay the bills for doing business with China. Previous regime did manage to get 1 billion yuan. If it necessitates, govt may go for another package when we need more credit to give our private sector to rejuvenate the economy.

Govt took some right steps to address inflation woes. Now it needs to unveil reform plans and address political uncertainty before it gets worse.

Monday, October 21, 2024

La Semaine Dernière A Mes Yeux




(19 octobre --- 25 octobre)

Cliquez pour voir/cacher
Ma Semaine Gastronomique
Date Petit déjeuner Déjeuner Dîner Snacks,Sucreries,Boissons et Fritures
19 Pain,Halwa du semoule Riz,Petit poisson,Soupe aux lentilles Riz,Lait ---
20 Pain,Halwa du semoule Riz,Épinard malabar,Ruhi Riz,Épinard malabar,Ruhi ---
21 Riz,Ruhi,Œuf Riz,Petit poisson,Pomme de terre Riz,Ruhi,Petit poisson ---
22 Pain,Citrouilles Riz,Poulet Riz,Ruhi,Poulet Prunier de cochon
23 Pain,Poulet Riz,Taro,Haricots rouge avec sec ruban Riz,Taro,Haricots rouge avec sec ruban ---
24 Khitchuri,Œuf,Poulet Riz,Taro,Pangash Riz,Taro,Pangash Biscuit
25 Riz,Œuf,Pangash Riz,Thankuni(ombelle asiatique),Pangash Riz,Thankuni,Pomme de terre Lait,Prunier du cochon

Friday, October 18, 2024

Tackling Inflation: Slash Price , Launch New Scope

Amid inflation, slashing prices is a must,
To save tiny savings, launch investment scope just.

Egg prices remain an issue in dealing with rising price levels. Despite increasing surveillance, prices are not lowered. For two days, big distributors stopped selling eggs as govt fixed prices for eggs at various stages. News reports say unusual precipitation hampered poultry farming across the country, causing shortfall of 5/8 million eggs daily. This is one of the reasons for unusual hike in egg prices. However, I disagree with the view that corporate groups bag huge profit from the unusual hike in poultry item prices. Swollen retained earnings presented as proof of foul play,but the profit before tax clearly shows size of profit corporate group usually generates1.It is not true that retained earnings show earnings after dividends. Rather it is reserved for paying dividends or reinvestment in the future at the will of corporation.

There is an increasing tendency to blame cartel/syndicate for the price hike in kitchen market. Back in March and August in 2023 in two pieces titled "Poultry Meat Gets Costlier" and "Poultry Market Becomes Volatile Again", I highlighted that there are too many farms and punishment is immediate in case of forming cartel in the poultry market2. Bangladesh Competition Commission fined two big farms and govt allowed import of Indian eggs. Then what is the point of forming cartel?

But there are signs of unholy alliance in the input market. Govt should probe on that. Like telecom business, govt may intervene in hatchery and feed production business to supply feed and chick to marginalized poultry farmers who find the feed prices too high.

Govt also needs to do a lot of things for hedging tiny savings against inflation. In our country, people do not have enough things to hedge their tiny savings against inflation except depositing money into bank accounts where interest rate is still lower than the true inflation rate. Govt is planning to allow ordinary people's investment into treasury bills which offer interest rate up to 12%. Problem is such investment requires minimum investment of Taka 100000 and it does not allow investment into treasury bills with 91-day or 180-day maturity. If small investors with Taka 500/1000/5000 are allowed to invest into such treasury bills, it would do a great help to them against inflation during the time of high price levels.

Similarly, ordinary people and micro savers' participation can be allowed into commodity exchange market where they can buy/sell futures ,options of commodities through banks/MFS. At the same time, foreign currency regulations act needs to be updated so that individuals can increase their foreign currency holdings in case of free fall of Taka or high inflation. Currently, the act forbids holding of foreign currency by individuals without valid documentation.

Lowering the price levels is a must step to give comfort from scorching heat of inflation. At the same time, it is no less important to protect peoples' savings.

References:

  1. "Dim ,Murgi Beche Fule Fepe Utchhey Boro Utpadak Protishthangulo(Big Producers Get Bigger By Selling Eggs,Poultry) ",Mehedi Hasan ,Bonikbarta, October 16,2024. Link: https://bonikbarta.com/bangladesh/dLzn4ol50hNoEqfH
  2. "Poultry Market Becomes Volatile Again",Rezaul Hoque, August 17,2023,https://hoquestake.blogspot.com.Link : https://hoquestake.blogspot.com/2023/08/poultry-market-becomes-volatile-again.html?m=1

Sunday, October 13, 2024

La Semaine Dernière A Mes Yeux




(12 octobre --- 18 octobre)

Cliquez pour voir/cacher
Ma Semaine Gastronomique
Date Petit déjeuner Déjeuner Dîner Snacks,Sucreries,Boissons et Fritures
12 Riz,Œuf,Ruhi Riz,Ruhi Riz,Ruhi ---
13 Khichuri,Œuf dur Pain,Lait Nouilles Prunier de cochon
14 Khichuri,Œuf dur Riz,Épinard d'eau,Pomme de terre Pain,Ruhi,Lait ---
15 Riz,Soupe aux lentilles,Papaye,Citrouilles Riz,Petit taro chinois,Koi poisson Pain,Petit taro chinois Pois chiches
16 Riz,Soupe aux lentilles,Banane verte,Koi poisson Riz,Poulet Pain,Poulet ---
17 Riz,Soupe aux lentilles,Poulet Riz,Courge amère,Épinard d'eau Riz,Poulet Nouilles
18 Pain,Pomme de terre,Citrouilles Riz,Épinard malabar,Pomme de terre,Citrouilles Riz,Épinard malabar,Petit poisson ---

Wednesday, October 9, 2024

Resume The Routine Work

To know inflation, introduce producer price index,
Resume routine work to ease the situation complex.

Bangladesh's inflation woes continue. Yet the govt is optimistic to contain the situation quickly. Meanwhile, flash flood caused by unusual rainfall is identified as one of the factors disrupting the supply chain. Poultry is hit by the flood to a great extent. At the same time, allegations of foul play in this particular sector are strong. Government allowed to import 40 million eggs from India to stabilize the egg market, which registered an unusual price of Taka 180/dozen. Consumers' protection body resumed their operation, identifying and catching red-handed few malpractitioners.

While government focuses on reforms( which are still being worked out) and election, routine functioning of a democratic govt is still missing. In my previous piece, I highlighted the role of regulatory bodies like BTRC,Competition Commission, BERC etc. Holding regular hearing and addressing pressing concerns, they somehow hold back malpractices in industry. A kind of check and balance. Similarly, parliament and parliamentary committee hold discussions and audition on key issues and call concerned persons / bodies to furnish their explanation. This particular form of check and balance is missing here. Because we are never allowed to practice it in the right way. So this interim govt could take a lead and initiate a subcommittee under the auspices of each ministry to hold hearing on pressing issues and offer solutions. It will lessen the workload of advisors. These subcommittees will keep a close tab on issues like price hike,law & order deterioration etc.

The issue of price hike is generating smoke. Two months passed since this govt took office, yet there is no improvement. Extortion, particularly political extortion is blamed for the rise in price level. Extortion to some extent is subdued ,yet price level is still rising. Here we focus too much on consumer price index, which mainly deals with prices at the retail level in cities. And selection of goods in calculation of CPI is highly questionable. But Producer Price Index(PPI) is often ignored. PPI focuses mainly on prices of ingredients needed to make final good. Price levels of ingredients, equipments should be monitored. Calculation of both PPI and CPI would reveal whether there is any distortion in the supply side. A corresponding change in CPI may be interpreted as price increase due to rise in price of raw-materials. If the change in CPI is larger than that of PPI,it may be concluded that some other factors are influencing prices in the distribution process. Allowing multiple parties to calculate both PPI and CPI would at least align the official data with the market data.

Idea of introducing license for wholesalers in the kitchen market was recently mooted. So that people with malevolent intentions stay away from kitchen market. I think registration with TIN and BIN in the wholesale market to a great extent curb market manipulation and stem entry of opaque capital in the market. But license/ registration process should be easy and flexible otherwise it will work as entry barrier and encourage black market for selling license like rickshaw license in Dhaka.

Chinese currency recently appreciated against the USD. It is good news for our exporters as Bangladeshi goods will be more competitive in the international market. China will relocate part of its manufacturing units abroad in the wake of rising cost at home.

Easing inflation and restoring law & order now depend on how the govt resumes the routine functioning and check and balance mechanism.

Tuesday, October 8, 2024

La Semaine Dernière A Mes Yeux




(05 octobre --- 11 octobre)

Cliquez pour voir/cacher
Ma Semaine Gastronomique
Date Petit déjeuner Déjeuner Dîner Snacks,Sucreries,Boissons et Fritures
05 Pain,Pomme de terre Riz,Poulet Riz,Poulet ---
06 Riz,Œuf,Gombo Riz,Puntio barbe avec pomme de terre Khichuri ---
07 Riz,Œuf Riz,Pangash,Gombo Pain,Pangash ---
08 Pain,Œuf Riz,Petit taro chinois,Pangash Pain,Pangash Biscuit
09 Pain,Halwa de semoule Riz,Épinard de malabar,Petit taro chinois Riz,Épinard de malabar,Petit taro chinois,Papaye,Soupe aux lentilles ---
10 Riz,Œuf,Papaye Riz,Papaye,Citrouilles,Pangash Riz,Pangash,Papaye,Citrouilles Biscuit
11 Riz,Citrouilles,Pangash Riz,Pangash,Soupe aux lentilles Riz,Ruhi Goyave

Thursday, October 3, 2024

Regulatory Grip Is Still Weak

No reflection of official data in market,
Allow others to make the data perfect.

September inflation data published by BBS shows marked decline in inflation. Average inflation declined to 9.92% and food inflation declined to 10.36%. It means for the two consecutive months average inflation declined. If the trend continues significant improvement in price levels may be observed by the end of this year. However, except rice, key kitchen commodities have yet to reflect the inflation data. At home rice registered decline in prices by Taka 4/5 per kilo. This is largely due to decline in prices at international market. India also lifted restrictions on export of non-Basmati rice. Coarse rice registered the marked decline.

Weak regulatory grip is more conspicuous. Despite Army and police presence, people are still being beaten to death. Law & order has yet to return to normalcy. A lack of accountability is still prevailing in the ground. Last week I noticed that mobile data pack prices were raised by all the operators in unison. This time volume of the data pack for shorter duration was also lowered. Moreover, the speed of the internet has yet to reach the pre-election level. Too many unrest, mob beating may be one of the reasons for slow speed. But the operators have not furnished any explanation yet. Unlike the previous regime, there is no whimsical imposition of tariff or duties. Then why is this price hike?

Reactivating BTRC's hearing on mobile phone services to a great extent address the issues. Similarly, resuming the operation of Bangladesh Competition Commission could make marked improvement in consumption behavior of the consumers and competition.

Since this regime does not have political loyalists/storm troopers on the ground or inside the administration ,there is a tendency not to respect their orders / instructions. Hopefully ,in the coming months their regulatory grip will be strengthened.

I think govt should also allow others to calculate and publish the consumer price index.Consumer's body,Bangladesh Bank, association of banks, market research firms or individuals should be allowed to do the CPI survey and publish the inflation data. Since inflation is affecting interest rate, vernacular activities, investment, it will be prudent to bring multiple parties to calculate the inflation and then have a discussion on them. Then govt can officially announce the true inflation data, emerging from so many studies. Economic data should reflect the market. Govt's own think tank's recent study reveals people's lack of confidence in govt data. Info on true situation in the ground and successful implementation of instructions are keys to have a firm regulatory grip.

Wednesday, October 2, 2024

La Semaine Dernière A Mes Yeux




(28 septembre --- 04 octobre)

Cliquez pour voir/cacher
Ma Semaine Gastronomique
Date Petit déjeuner Déjeuner Dîner Snacks,Sucreries,Boissons et Fritures
28 Pain,Œuf poché,Pomme de terre Riz,Petit taro chinois avec sec ruban poisson,Épinard d'eau Riz,Petit taro chinois avec sec ruban poisson,Épinard d'eau ---
29 Pain,omelette Riz,Ruhi,Soupe aux lentilles,Papaye Riz,Soupe aux lentilles,Papaye Nouilles
30 Pain,Pomme de terre Riz,Pomme de terre,Latya Pain,Latya ---
01 Khichuri,Omelette Riz,Courge amère,Soupe aux lentilles Riz,Pomme de terre,Lentilles ---
02 Riz,Soupe aux lentilles,Œuf Riz,Ruhi Riz,Ruhi ---
03 Pain,Œuf Riz,Bulbous root of arum with dried ribbon Riz,Bulbous root of arum with dried ribbon ---
04 Pain,Pomme de terre Riz,Poulet Riz,Poulet ---