La Semaine Dernière A Mes Yeux

(04 mars --- 11mars)

Selon un reportage, incendie a ravagé 300 toits de chaume à Ukhia,Cox's Bazar. 20 personnes ont été brûlées. Un enfant a été tué.

Selon un reportage, cadavres de 4 membres de Mogh Liberation Party ont été trouvé au bord du fleuve à Roangchhari,Bandarban. Le groupe était responsible d’avoir abdiqué un dirigeant de Jana Sanghati Samiti. Il y a une éruption de violence dans les premiers deux mois de 2022 à Roangchhari et Ruma,situé à la proximité de la frontière Bangla-Birmanie.

Selon un reportage, une société sri lankaise a détenu toutes les actions de première marque de supershop bangladais. Tous les deux n'ont pas divulgué le montant dans lequel la marque a été vendue. Tous les deux n’ont pas divulgué le montant dans lequel la marque a été vendue.

An Interview And Power Of Pacifism

Passive resistance and power of pacifism
Make strong Bangladesh and end jingoism.

A Bangladeshi daily recently took an interview of head of Arakan Army,a group fighting for independence in Rakhine State of Myanmar. Key takeaways of that interview are: Arakan Army signed a ceasefire agreement with Tatmadaw,it maintains a 30000-strong army, it recognizes Rohingyas as “Muslims of Rakhine State”,it wants to play role in resolving the Rohingya crisis and awaits Bangladesh response,situation in Rakhine State is not conducive for Rohingya repatriation,its parallel administration in Rakhine State employs local Muslims, armed Muslim cadre of Arakan Army recently defected and joined ARSA, and Bangladesh does not like its activity in Bangladeshi side and it honors Bangladesh’s stance¹.

The interview was published at a time when UN rapporteur on human rights situation in Myanmar in a press conference claimed that UN has information on ARSA activities inside the Rohingya camps of Bangladesh². Prior to that a Rohingya leader was shot dead by assailants believed to be ARSA cadres. Slain leader Muhibullah played crucial role in mobilizing Rohingyas to raise their demand for trying Myanmar Army for the brutality against Rohingya.

Despite the relative calm in the Rakhine State due to the ceasefire agreement,clashes erupted in neighboring Chin State and other parts of Myanmar.

Bangladesh so far did the right thing to keep itself aloof from the internal turbulence of Myanmar. However, in the past, Bangladeshi authority detained several separatists from CHT and ceased and destroyed many poppy and cannabis fields whose ownership remained mystery though publicly it was claimed that those were operated by separatist groups of both the countries. CHT has a heavy presence of armed forces personnel.

Invasion of methamphetamine at ease also questions willingness of its security establishment to contain the problem. The problem is so grave that killing of a retired Army officer by a Police officer almost created rift between the govt and the Army. And extrajudicial killing of a counselor in Cox's Bazaar resulted in imposition of sanction against key personnel of RAB and Police.

Despite being a suspect, Tatmadaw did far more better job in nabbing drug kingpins. Tatmadaw cooperated with international press to unearth the drug operations inside its territory. Such effort helped international authority to arrest a drug lord in Europe,known as “El Chapo of Asia”³.Meanwhile, Bangladesh authority always throws cold water to any such initiative and even put up hurdles in doing report by international press. Even it remained silent to Tatmadaw’s accusations of infiltrating drug-making ingredients inside Myanmar. Tatmadaw was just echoing an UNODC report that shared some chilling findings on drug trade in this region. According to UNODC report, size of methamphetamine market in Bangladesh is $5.5 billion⁴. Without endorsement of security establishment, such trade cannot continue unabated. In addition, such illicit trade is key to sustain insurgent groups and cadre-based political parties which are aplenty in this part of the world.

Many army-backed group in the past found involved in accumulating wealth abroad and investment in troubled region of Bangladesh. Sikder Group created a storm in the tea cup by purchasing land from Sena Kalyan Sangstha in Bandarban,few kilometers away from Myanmar border, in a bid to set up a five-star hotel. Indigenous Mro people protested the purchase arguing the land belonged to them and it threatened their livelihood⁵. The group has investments in Thailand and Caribbean Islands⁶. Earlier, Singapore authority froze an account of $1 billion belonged to an individual from Bangladesh⁷. News report of local daily revealed that it belongs to a Bangladeshi politician who was hanged by Bangladesh for war crimes. He was advisor of parliamentary affairs to former Prime Minister and his family owns QC shipping line and private container depot among other ventures. It was unknown how Salahuddin Quader Chowdhury amassed such wealth abroad. List goes on. A Bangladeshi businessman enters the list of billionaires of Singapore⁸. He is brother of a ruling party politician who also headed parliamentary committee on defense. The Summit Group like Quader Chowdhury also operates a cargo container service (riverine), an inland container depot and an LNG terminal.

Despite being a democratic county (non-functioning),we have institutions that have no accountability to people.Such lacking in turn help fostering criminal activities and groups.

Tatmadaw fares well in contrast to our ones.From one of earlier posts,sharing my views on Tatmadaw:

Unlike other regional armies, Tatmadaw has some unique features. It is an organization that was not modeled after the outgoing colonial master's army and that does not hinge on its former colonial master to train its personnel as some of its neighbors do. Home-grown and oriental orientation to training and grooming of future military leaders have its pros and cons. Often in our region we see regional armies have officers whose views and convictions are moulded by the country of origin of their trainers. At various stages, they developed some kind of split loyalty and embarked upon misadventures that froze constitution and took away freedom of expression for several years. This derailment of democracy, often happens through bloody events, crippled institutions that are quintessential to flourish democracy⁹.

Following an impasse in the repatriation process and a World Bank policy framework on refugee management inside Bangladesh, a former Foreign Secretary wrote the following in his column:

They have to fight their own struggles and others can only assist them. No sign is there among them. Are they waiting for angels to send them back to their homeland? No such thing happened to ethnic groups who had been displaced for many reasons.

Following the assumption of power by Myanmar military, NLD and other small parties formed a coalition government. Many ethnic guerrilla groups joined them. But no one recognizes it, even Bangladesh does not recognize it. Bangladesh should not recognize it. But no recognition does not bar one to have contact with such government. Indirect contact could be set up and an understanding should be reached in a bid to resolve the Rohingya crisis. … this government pledged to resolve the Rohingya crisis, no matter how fragile that pledge is,Rohingyas should step forward. Not that every Rohingya will play an armed role,but could play the role of close confident.For the sake of long term interest,Bangladesh needs to play a role to make a close contact between Rohingya and NLD-led coalition government. Small investment could yield better harvest. Nothing guarantees resolving the crisis,but useless it is to miss the chances,be it big or small.¹⁰

Last year in August 15,I penned a piece titled “What’s In A Name?“. Sharing parts of it again:

I think Bangladesh should abstain from entertaining any armed misadventure to put an end to Rohingya crisis. It will not only harm image of Bangladesh,but will also engender our relationship with our neighbors. Pitfalls lie in such ideas could unsettle and undo any short term gains.Look at Pakistan. Despite being one of the victims of terrorism, its built-in image makes it a less trustworthy partner in international community.Its democratic institutions are in tatters as domestic and foreign policies were decided by others ignoring people’s representatives and the Parliament.

Bangladesh should not tread on that path as such steps may hurt our image and may ostracize us in international community. Moreover,we inked a bilateral deal with Myanmar regarding repatriation of the Rohingyas. Any misadventure may put on hold that process and cost us losing the Myanmar Army that has been in charge of running the country for the last six decades and may do so for the next six decades or so. They are the only powerful institution in that country and has considerable leverages on the country and people. Myanmar as a country is a delicate case in the region. China,Thailand and India all house thousands of ethnic Myanmar groups. But never support directly any armed struggles against the Tatmadaw. And the countries maintain good relations and help it militarily¹¹.

From the interview of Arakan Army chief, it has become clear the Rakhine State is not safe for Rohingya repatriation. Frustrations of Bangladeshi policymakers over the issue also worry ordinary citizens as it may lead to choosing a wrong step.

The prolonged nature of the Rohingya crisis makes donor agencies’ suggestion for access to education, setting up business, land purchase and access to credit more tenable. The measures will make them less vulnerable to the lures of evil quarters, will empower them and thereby will reduce the risks coming from the camp-dwelling Rohingyas.

Without any mainstream education and livelihood opportunities, there is a risk that they may fall victims of regimented groups by subscribing to non-mainstream education. It will make the Rohingya management much more difficult. No matter which sides of the border the Rohingyas reside in, educated Rohingyas will be true asset for both the countries.

I think the best way to mitigate the Rohingya crisis is to reach out all levels of civilian and military leadership in Myanmar and allow them to reap the benefits of Bangladesh economy¹¹.

At the end of the day, image of brand Bangladesh matters us a lot than anything else. Pacifism, standing for the just cause,respecting international laws,territorial integrity of others and passive resistance not only help maintaining high moral ground but also make strong brand Bangladesh. Housing millions of stateless people does not weaken Bangladesh. Rather it strengthens its image and influence.

Notes And References:

1 “Amra Rohingyader Nagarik Odhikar Shikar Kori(We Recognize Rohingyas' Right To Citizenship)”,Ashfaq Roni,Shafiqul Alam and Altaf Parvez,Daily Prothom Alo,January, 02,2022

2 “UN Rights Envoy Calls For Global Efforts To Cut Fund Flow For Myanmar Military Junta”,bdnews24.com,December 19,2021 Link here

3 “Tse Che Lop: Alleged Asian Drug Lord Arrested In Amsterdam”,BBC,January 24,2021,Link here

4 “UNODC Report And Meth Market Of Bangladesh “,Rezaul Hoque, https://hoquestake.blogspot.com ,July 25,2019 Link here

5 “Mro People Protest ‘Hill-Land Grabbing' For 5-Star Hotel,Tourist Spot “,Daily Star,November 09,2020,Link here

6 “Las Vegas Soho Boro Boro Shohore Sikdar Group Er Bipul Sompod(Sikder Group Perks Wealth In Las Vegas And Other Cities)”,Daily Prothom Alo,June 09,2020,Link here

7 “Singapore Aat Hajar Koti Taka'r Malik Me?(Who Is The Owner Of $1 Billion In Singapore?) ”,Bangladesh Protidin,November 28,2020,Link here

8 “Summit’s Aziz 34th Richest In Singapore:Forbes",Daily Star,August 16,2018,Link here

9 “Don’t Discard Tatmadaw”,Rezaul Hoque,https://hoquestake.blogspot.com,November 24,2019Link here

10 “Rohingyader Jatigoto Shodhoner Pokkhe Bishwa Bank?(World Bank For Ethnic Cleansing Of The Rohingyas?)”,Towhid Hossain,Daily Prothom Alo,August 12,2021.

11“What’s In A Name?”,Rezaul Hoque,https://hoquestake.blogspot.com,August 15,2021,Link here

Man Vs Wild

A trivial news emanating from Boalkhali of Chattogram caught me off guard. The news reads three lives perished in an attack by elephant herd. One met the death while gardening his cultivable land. The other person was struck by an elephant while he was picking arum leaves behind a saw-mill. An elderly man was trampled down by a herd of elephants after he had finished his morning prayers. Earlier, two baby elephants had been killed: one was drowned in a pond and another one was electrocuted by a trap set by villagers. Villagers claimed more and more elephants descended on villages, located on the fringes of forests of South Chattogram and Bandarban, in search of food. This is happening due to shortages of foods in the woods.

This tragedy is a stark reminder that trappings of development are making a heavy dent in the nature. The result is obvious: the elephants could not sustain in receding forests and devoured the surrounding paddy fields on far too many occasions.

This tragic encounter is also taking place in other parts of Bangladesh: in Moulvibazar wild cats are caught by locals while they try to catch fish. In villages close to Sundarban, Royal Bengal Tigers often prey on livestock. In Rajshahi, a mango orchard is occupied by Shamuk Khol birds' nests, prompting local administration to issue notice against orchard owner of causing any damage to the nests and doling out compensation.

Stray incidents call for urgent policy action so that man and wild can live in harmony. Many of our neighboring countries make great progress in this regard, significantly reducing incidence of tragic encounters and loss of property. Bangladesh can draw lessons from them.

To accommodate growing population, houses are being built in cultivable lands. Cultivable lands are being used to grow cash crops that fetch more money for farmers. Moreover, for the sustenance of growing population, forests turn into cultivable lands. For this reason we see paddy fields invade forests where elephants roam free. Trees used to grow in the woods were cut down and agricultural land were transformed into orchards. So desperate birds like Shamuk Khol make nests on mango tree tops. Pisciculture is so widespread and profitable that no pond or ditch is left unused for desperate "mechho bagh" or Fish Tigers to fill their stomach. Thin vegetation, disappearance of mangrove forests due to increased human settlement and agricultural activity are pushing the deer stock further from the reach of tigers. Evidently the hungry Maharajas raided the nearby villages in search of food and made headlines on the newspaper.

Development and preservation of forest can go hand in hand, contrary to the argument that stresses on the tradeoff between the two. A symbiotic relationship could be explored so that the two could coexist in harmony.

Peasants would not lay traps if there were incentive /compensation to damaged crops stemming from marauding elephants. Subject to the report of forestry officials in the wake of such incident, local administration could hand down cash or subsidized rice, more than the value of damaged crops,to the victims. In this situation, any approaching herd of elephant does not pose any threat to harvest, so the peasant is no longer hostile to elephants. Meanwhile, the starving elephant gets an alternate source of food in the paddy fields and becomes more docile at a later date.

Shamuk Khol nest incident in Rajshahi is an eye opener. There local administration gave words to the orchard owner that he would be duly compensated and issued a notice for not obliterating the nests. The assurance and local support from the villagers salvaged the nests.

Similarly, Sunderban villagers could be given wild hogs or piglets so that the tigers prey on them instead of the cattle. Proper training can be introduced to take care of the mangrove forests. In addition, subsidized rice could be distributed among villagers who comply government instructions to preserve the forest and to be kind to the wild.

Local administration and forestry officials could initiate advocacy campaign in the target area in a bid to disseminate information on incentives. Awareness building is at the core of this advocacy campaign. Special job program and scholarship for children at school in target area could also be introduced.

Most of our public fund is squandered away because of corrupted projects and mismanagement. Projects aimed to preservation of the wild will not demand more money. Government could easily allocate fund for this kind of initiative that will in the end bridge two hostile communities.

In Africa, parents of a newborn of a primitive society take the umbilical cord to a nearby forest and bury it. It is done so that the baby develops a bond to mother nature and performs its duty diligently at a later stage.

This kind of practice is conspicuously absent in our society, which receives lights of education and enjoys all the marvels of modernity. Government cannot sit idle and needs to act fast.

Any encounter with wild tiger may end up with tragic consequences. But that does not bar humans to preserve endangered species like tigers. Because we know the value of such species in nature and have the vision about what the world will look like without them. For this reason, elephant trek, Shamuk Khol nest, safe preying zone for fish tigers and undisturbed habitat for Royal Bengal tigers should be included in our development agenda. A society is recognized as developed when it mourns loss of its wild. Do we really progress to that stage?