Showing posts with label Cryptocurrency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cryptocurrency. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 20, 2025

Tax On Remittances: Good Or Bad?

The big bill propels another currency de facto,
Back from the brink rises again the crypto.

The Trump administration has introduced a bill "One Big Beautiful Act", suggesting imposition of 5% tariff on all kinds of outward remittances. There is widespread fear here that it would lower the remittances from the USA. It is too early to make such comment. The decision would undoubtedly allow the US govt to bag huge amount of revenue to address its huge deficits.

The tariff debate, weakening of US dollar , tax on remittances hint that the US want to ease the pressure on US dollar demand. At the same time, it would encourage alternate mode of transfer. Cryptocurrency witnesses unprecedented surge after having severe regulatory restrictions across the globe. Weakening of dollar also means reduced purchasing power of the holder of dollar denominated assets. One would [in] such scenario try to convert the money into other currencies or invest in assets where one's money will grow. If one wants to invest abroad in spite of having serious restrictions at home or wants to avoid political controversy ,alternate mode of transfer and exchange would become popular. So here the cryptocurrency comes into play. Following the onset of the war in Europe, many billionaires in Russia and China transferred their wealth abroad in the face of severe restrictions at home. Weakening Yuan may be good for competitiveness but it also hit hard the purchasing power of the rich if their assets are in Yuan. In addition, there is a thing called "portfolio risk" that may hurt balance sheet of the company if its domestic return on investment is too low compared to return on investment abroad. Sometimes it casts shadow over the existence of the company. That is why there is a tremendous rush to invest/ transfer wealth abroad. As govt regulations become rigid, many try to depend on alternate mode of transfer like crypto / bitcoin in order to avoid controversy. As more people switch to this mode of transfer, it becomes mainstream and calls for global convention for its operations. In the past, organized criminal groups used this channel due to lack of global convention. Future of bitcoins depends on how this mode of transfer/exchange behaves in a world of rising protectionism and growing demand for deregulation. This is where the US tax on remittances [sets] the course for further revival of this alternate mode of transfer.

The UAE based exchange houses raised fees by 15% for outward remittances in 2024. But they kept the money-sending apps out of this regulation( For more see "Remittance Er Mashul 15% Briddhi Korbe Arab Amirat,Probashider Khoroch Barbs(UAE To Raise Fees For Remittances By 15%,Migrant Worker's Cost Will Rise)", Daily Ittefaq,April 9,2024). Despite the fee hike, the UAE became the second highest remittance source for Bangladesh in 2024. The rise in fees did not have severe impact on remittances for Bangladesh.

Imposition of tax on remittances will raise the cost for remitters. It will also eat away the gain of speculators and opportunistic groups who launder money abroad through trade invoices and remit back the money to siphon off govt subsidies. Free floating of Taka has made that money laundering activity even more costlier.

The remittance tax also made the prospect of launching apps for sending money by Bangladesh Bank /local bank even brighter. It will gain the trust of the remitters and prevent the accumulation of funds into wrong hands.

The tax on remittances at one hand resurrects the bitcoin by drawing people and popularizing it, and on the other hand opens up new opportunity in Bangladesh by preventing the money laundering activity. Drawing the lessons from UAE changes, we hope that this change will also bring good to us.

Friday, September 16, 2022

Bangladesh Bans Bitcoin

For money laundering,MFS gets the blame,
TK 750 billion gone as per Police claim.
Central bank reminds ban on cryptocurrency,
Consultation is key to stop this tendency.

Recently, Bangladesh Bank issued a circular banning bitcoin in Bangladesh. Credit cards issued by local banks and Mobile Financial Services (MFS) are increasingly being used to do transaction in bitcoin,noted Bangladesh Bank1. Bangladesh does not allow virtual currency. So bitcoin is illegal.

The ban came in the wake of a police investigation that claimed TK 750 billion were laundered abroad in the last ten years through MFS and commercial banks. And in the last one year TK 250 billion were smuggled out of the country through MFS,which plays a crucial role in digital inclusion of the mass.

In recent years,e-commerce platforms came under intense criticism following a series of scams in the e-commerce sector.Many crooked e-commerce platforms swindled clients' money. Recently row over ownership of a newly launched MFS platform between a company and Bangladesh Post Office called into question objectives of such platforms.However, it did not bar people from subscribing to such platforms and do transaction. The same platform is the object of a fresh debate after it failed to repay part of a loan to a commercial bank as it lacks enough money to pay back the loan.

I do not think it is quite right to put the blame squarely on MFS operators for all the wrongdoings. Some crooked owners and clients are mostly behind in this kind of debate.

There is no doubt that some bad quarters use bit coin to do illicit transaction.But there is no point to get strict with MFS operators. And government does not have mechanism to stop such transactions. Country like El Salvador, where organized criminal groups hold sway over govt,only legalized bitcoin. But it does not mean bitcoin in general is associated with all the bad things. If proper law and other international regulations are put in place,bitcoin could be used to use as a tender in doing transaction with countries that are forced to quit international payment platforms like SWIFT. Particularly true for countries which have obligations to pay loan instalment but cannot do because of sanctions on creditor country.

But it is unsafe and risky in doing transaction in bitcoin as most of the countries do not recognize it and there are inadequate laws and regulations for its governance.However, govt can allow setting up facilities for bitcoin mining for other countries. In Kazakhstan, a Chinese company set up such a facility and paid the govt fees. It stores virtual currency related data. Such facility consumes a lot of electricity2.

Recently, a Chinese company approached Dhaka North City Corporation and offered to invest in setting up a power plant producing electricity from garbage. The Company will do all the investment and DNCC has to purchase the electricity at a predetermined price3. Few megawatts of electricity do not call for such proposal.

Currently we have many rental and captive power plants for industrial use. I fear many such plants may be used for bitcoin mining operations. When you are producing RMG items or other industrial items ,price of electricity could play a role in fixing the price of good in a bid to maintain competitive edge. But when you are clandestinely operating such facility you are doing great disservice to subsidized electricity. Electricity bill for such mining facility should not be same as those for an industrial unit.Govt is also deprived of vital revenue. If govt allows such facility,govt will get regular revenue and higher prices for electricity.

This should also be applicable for individuals who operate such facility at micro level.

Central bank did the right thing by banning the bitcoin. But MFS operators are not part of the problems when millions of people do transactions worth billions of Taka daily. Rather,they have to be consulted to devise a durable mean to reduce incidence of money laundering.

Notes And References:

  1. "Bangladesh Bank Warns Against Accepting Export Proceeds In And Buying Cryptocurrency",bdnews24.com,September 15,2022. For more read at https://tinyurl.com/4b7tfz7h
  2. "China Crypto Miners Turn To Kazakhstan ",Forkast News. For more see at https://tinyurl.com/bdfvkjvc
  3. "Waste To Electricity:China To Build Powerplant For DNCC Areas", Rejaul Karim Byron and Helemul Alam,Daily Star,November 13,2020. For more read at https://tinyurl.com/bdezjc3h