Showing posts with label Fiscal Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fiscal Policy. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Saving Banks: Not With Our Money

BB's plan to make ailing banks better
Allows business as usual and fuels inflation later.

The central bank governor in a program reiterated Bangladesh Bank's plan to draw budget money or taxpayers' money for providing support to ailing banks. Bangladesh Bank (BB) governor quite clearly spelled out that Tk 600 billion may require annually for 5 or 8 years to support the troubled banks and govt budget may provide this money. Governor also said in the past govt borrowed enough money and the future generation would bear the cost of paying for this money and mismanagement of the govt.

As I mentioned in an earlier piece "A Recipe To Keep Economy On Steroids", published here on October 20,2026(see https://hoquestake.blogspot.com/2026/10/a-recipe-to-keep-economy-on-steroids.html?m=1) the central bank's plan to bail out troubled banks means the money for such plan would partly come from taxpayers' money and partly from printing money amid weak revenue mobilization. And the plan is tantamount to keep the economy on steroids since large part of the money would come from printing money due to subdued economic activity.

Governor squarely places the responsibility of rescuing the ailing banks on the taxpayers. BB's plan will require between Tk 3 trillion (for 5 years) and Tk 4.8 trillion (for 8 years). Despite the dependence on taxpayers' money, things may not look that easy as it appears. The bank support program alone will need $4.8 billion annually. Plus the govt has to manage additional $8.5 billion to implement the new pay scale. For the moment, mobilizing revenue to meet this annual additional cost of $13.3 billion looks like an uphill task.

Recently ,a news report divulged that govt started implementing its plan. The news said BB sought govt assistance of Tk 27 billion to bail out 9 troubled Non Bank Financial Institutions (NBFIs). The govt response to the request is not clear. If govt nods to the proposal, then the money will either come from the bloc grant of the budget or scrapping another project.

Why should the taxpayers pay for the plundering of financial institutions? As I said in an earlier piece, some miscreants got away with the bank money and the taxpayers would pay for the misdeed. This is not just unjust, this is not the right way to solve the banking problem. Moreover, it is not right to tell the future generation to be ready to pay the price for wrongdoings they did not commit. Someone did the wrong and someone else will pay the price --- this kind of mindset requires to be changed to address the problem in the banking sector.

If the central bank sticks to this line of thinking, then it will set a bad precedent for the future wrongdoers in the banking sector. Bailing out troubled institutions at the expense of taxpayers' money and govt money/reserve money may invite further irregularities in the financial sector. Not only the domestic plunderers, but corrupt people from abroad may flock here to take the money out from the domestic banking system. Hard working people will save money into the banks and a bunch of plunderers may steal those money at regular intervals with flawed govt policy! Is this the reality the central bank envisages for the financial sector of the country?

Central bank's bailing out of banks at the cost of taxpayers' money and reserve money creates another issue: the soft budget constraint. This phenomenon was observed by Hungarian economist Jànos Kornai while studying the firms of his country. The soft budget constraint occurs when an entity anticipates that some other entity or someone else is going to cover its losses. This anticipation leads it to indulge in taking more risky ventures, overspending and delaying reforms.

The present plan of bank support provides incentive for banks to do business as usual that led them to current precarious situation. Moreover, management board and stakeholders of financial institutions do not feel the urge to commit themselves in greater reform that will lead to improvement in governance in these institutions. Unviable project and fraudulent scheme may get bank money as the institutions know govt may come up with funds if they run into troubles.

I do not think only taxpayers' money will prop up the central bank's current plan for banks. The first four months of this fiscal year witnessed a shortfall of Tk 500 billion in revenue collection. We have to remember that this fiscal year is a transition year as govt reset the fiscal year March-April instead of June-July. More borrowing is another option though borrowing from abroad is becoming tough. In addition, govt's annual debt servicing will reach $7.5 billion years down the line. So govt may lean towards banks for borrowing. And here comes the possibility of govt's money printing initiative.

Devolvement, overdraft, ways and means advances and suspense accounts are the tools through which BB prints money and injects into the system (see "How printing money without creating real assets fuelled inflation", Jebun Nesa Alo, The Business Standard, November 10,2024, https://www.tbsnews.net/economy/banking/how-printing-money-without-creating-real-assets-fuelled-inflation-989106). Devolvement,which is central bank's purchase of treasury bills and bonds after issuing them, has been halted since August 2023 following instructions from the IMF. However, overdraft, ways and means advances and suspense accounts are still operational to print money. Money printing without creating real assets means inflation. Most likely, govt may exploit the overdraft and ways and means advances facilities within the central bank to inject huge money into the banking system. And later part of the money will be used to provide the banking support program of the central bank.

In any standard, the central bank's bank support plan is reckless in nature as it passes the responsibility of mismanagement and corruption from wrongdoers to the taxpayers and govt. Other means are not sorted out yet. Govt would facilitate forming the distress asset management company to deal with the distressed assets of the troubled banks. Govt may think of speeding up the process of stolen asset recovery. Since plundering happened in the last couple of years, present generation should bear a large part of the tax burden. It may include doubling or tripling the turnover tax on profitable companies of high profile defaulters, special duties on interest payment of National Savings Certificates (NSCs), raising taxes on capital gains, raising surcharges on cars, holding tax and registration fees on apartment sales. Most pragmatic way is to let some troubled institutions die.

The future generation should no way pay the price for bank looting. Govt signals not to reduce the energy subsidy, not to go after bank plunderers but contemplates that people and govt may fill the void in the banks created by bank looters. This line of thinking should be discarded. Either thinking should be changed or governor should be changed. We cannot simply entertain a plan that encourages business as usual in the financial sector and fuels inflation in the future.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Keep The Spending In Check

Keep govt spending low
For stable economy and FDI flow.

By keeping govt spending in check, we can also check other crucial indicators like budget deficit, govt borrowing, liquidity to private sector, exchange rate and investment. Unwarranted govt spending is not only a waste of taxpayer's money, it also raises tax burden [for] future taxpayers. Take for instance, Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) project,which was conceived to link the Dhaka-Gajipur through an exclusive bus lane, curtailing time and hastle commuters endure in this route. Govt last week scrapped the project, which is marred with corruption and serious design flaws, after spending nearly Tk 48 billion for more than a decade! Semi-complete structures of the project mock govt's lack of vision and management abilities.

Projects like BRT have become common phenomena nowadays. Meanwhile, revenue mobilization does not reach the desired pace. In the first four months of this fiscal year, National Board of Revenue (NBR) manages to collect Tk 1.27 trillion as revenue against a target of Tk 1.77 trillion, registering a shortfall of Tk 500 billion,as per data furnished by the NBR. Subdued economic activity and low revenue mobilization lead to more borrowing for the govt. According to "International Debt Report 2026" by the World Bank, Bangladesh's foreign debt reaches $113.48 billion in 2026. Bangladesh's foreign debt to GDP ratio rose to 26 percent. This borrowing is making dent into revenue resources as well as casting shadow over investment.

S&P Global Ratings earlier observed that govt revenue collection accounts for 8% -- 9% of GDP and interest payments represent 30% of govt revenue.

That means revenue collection is still inadequate and more than a quarter of that revenue goes for paying up interest payment of govt debt. And the external debt servicing is rising. In 2022-23, external debt servicing was $3 billion. In 2025-26, it rose to $4.5 billion.

With falling revenue, budget deficit is on the rise. The World Bank projects budget deficit will be 4.8% in 2027 and 4.9% in 2028. To finance the growing budget deficit, govt has to borrow more from the domestic and foreign sources. Since financial account is on deficit, govt is likely to finance budget deficit by borrowing from local banks and printing money.

Indications are already there. There are reports that the central bank seeks Tk 27 billion from govt to bail out 9 troubled Non Bank Financial Institutions (NBFIs), which witnessed unprecedented plundering in the past. Govt also revives many unviable public projects that the interim govt deemed doomed.

Point is the aura of austerity is conspicuously missing from the govt. Since financing the budget deficit is becoming difficult amid existing challenges, the most easy task is to cut govt spending. It will help keeping the budget deficit low.

A low budget deficit is very much likeable to foreign investors as it will not have an impact on investment return. Countries even passed law to keep budget deficit low. For instance, Indonesia introduced a law that requires govt keep budget deficit below 3% of GDP, taking lessons from the 1997 financial disaster. This fiscal prudence made Indonesia an attractive destination for foreign investment.

Moreover, govt's increasing borrowing from the domestic banks curtails credit to private sector, which registered a 4.75% growth in August this year. This further chokes economic activity as private investment suffers from lack of credit.

Irrational govt spending and lack of financing sources often put pressure on local currency. And too much volatility in the currency in short span of time not only discourages foreign investment but also accelerates the clandestine capital flight. For fall in the local currency reduces the wealth of the Rich at home, many prefer to launder money abroad to mitigate currency volatility. And wild fall of the local currency also deteriorates the inflation. So it has become a matter of paramount importance to keep govt spending in check.

Though it is difficult for political govt to keep govt spending low, it has to be done for the sake of economy in the long run. Macroeconomic stability and keeping inflation low should be at the heart of govt economic policies. In that light, cutting govt spending vies for top position of the govt priority list and such move touches lives and livelihoods of millions of people by insulating them from the detrimental effects of irrational govt spending.

Thursday, April 9, 2026

Revenue Reform Remains Unimplemented

Throwing the revenue reform into the gutter
Is not silly but a serious matter.

It appears that the ruling party has kept its words by not implementing the revenue reform. At the heart of this reform is the separation between revenue policy department and revenue implementation department. Past interim govt even made Revenue Policy and Revenue Administration Ordinance 2025 (see http://bdlaws.minlaw.gov.bd/act-details-1537.html),which is in line with the IMF reform list. Incumbent Finance Minister before the election said his party would support independence of the central bank but oppose splitting the NBR into two bodies.

What does this new ordinance contain? Govt will appoint people to revenue policy department. Tax Appellate Tribunal and Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal will be under the auspices of revenue policy department. Its jobs include formulation of tax policy, raising/lowering taxes, tax law amendment, evaluation of tax management, negotiations on international customs agreement, research, revenue forecast and estimation among other things.

Staffs of revenue administration department will be drawn from BCS cadres. Revenue administration is tasked with implementation of various tax laws and regulations, implementation of international customs agreement, implementation of international agreement on abolition of double taxation, staff management, making and implementing budget for the department, initiating tax awareness building campaign,undertaking audit and surveillance programs etc.

The splitting of the NBR will make the policy department's influence weaker over the administration department. At present NBR could impose excise duties or [raise] taxes in the middle of the year in a bid to meet the revenue target. The move ultimately increases cost of doing business. Many investment initiatives sustain cost overrun because of unpredictable nature of tax policies. It is anticipated that NBR reform would bring predictability in tax policies [by] not raising cost of businesses in a given year.

And most importantly the reform may put an end to policies driven by political vendetta. The NBR Order of 1972 makes NBR a powerful institution. If one reads the clause #4 of The NBR Order, then one can have some idea about the power wielded by the NBR. The clause states that govt can make rules at its whims and NBR officers can take actions whatever they wish before the rule is actually made. Those actions before the rule cannot be put under scanner later (see The NBR Order 1972, https://nbr.gov.bd/uploads/acts/9.pdf). In the past we saw how the NBR was used to harass the political opponent. Fear is that outrightly throwing the idea of splitting the NBR may continue political vendetta driven actions.

Revenue reform will not only put restraint over overwhelming power of NBR,it will also bring the much needed predictability about revenue policymaking. And it will benefit both business and individual alike in terms of giving idea about the vernacular cost. At the same time, it will improve the political environment by ending use of NBR as a docile instrument to harass others. But by not making the ordinance into a law , govt throws cold water into such bright possibilities. I hope govt will reconsider its decision.

Thursday, April 2, 2026

Rising Public Debt Clips The Wings

The woe called rising public debt
Makes difficult choices amid revenue regret.

Govt is planning to seek $2 billion foreign credit to mitigate challenges of energy security caused by ongoing war. Meanwhile, govt's debt service management has already crossed $3 billion matching the incoming flow of aid this fiscal year. Asian Development Bank hinted that it [would] provide credit to meet the emerging need from oil price shock. Ailing economy needs further cash to recover. And it is coming from foreign credit. Bangladesh's overall foreign credit stands at $113.51 billion at the end of December 2025. Govt borrowing accounts for 82% of the total foreign credit. Private sector accounts for the rest.(Source: Bangladesh Bank)

According to a study by IMF,global public debt reached 93.9% of GDP and projected to cross 100% by 2028(see "High Debt,Hard Choices" by Era Dabla-Norris and Rodrigo Valdes,March 2026,IMF,https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2026/03/high-debt-hard-choices-era-dabla-norris). As the public debt rises,so does the interest payment. This fiscal year alone govt paid $950 million as interest payment. By the end of this fiscal year it would cross the billion [dollar] mark. The situation makes the task of resource mobilization even harder. The IMF study also shows that interest payments take away 21% of tax revenues in low income countries. This money could have been spent on social security programs and development programs.

Tax revenues that help financing the development and social security programs are not in a good shape. Against a target of Tk 3.25 trillion ,NBR managed to collect Tk 2.54 trillion of revenue till February this year, registering a shortfall of Tk 714 billion(Source: NBR). This year revenue target is set at Tk 5.54 trillion. Failure to meet revenue target means the money has to come from somewhere else. Borrowing is a popular option. As Bangladesh is scheduled to graduate from LDC countries within two years, overseas borrowing will be costly for us. Battered economy, poor credit ratings have already made costly the foreign credit. Too much borrowing from domestic sources translates into less credit to private sector. What is worrying too much borrowing amid high debt and inadequate revenue has consequences. The IMF study cautions:

"But today, the era of easy choices is over. Every dollar a government borrows without matching revenue implies higher taxes or lower spending in the future, at least to cover the additional interest the new debt generates. Beyond a certain point, more borrowing forces painful decisions—through austerity, inflation, financial repression, or even default."

Amid the grim fiscal situation, govt undertakes ambitious social security programs where chances of leakages are very high. Previous social security programs were not leakages free. Given no dramatic improvement in governance in the last one year, why will these new ones be different? Meanwhile, borrowed money will finance the deficit budget and tax revenues will go for paying the rising debt instead of development or social security programs. Earlier we used to take debt to finance various programs [aimed] for people and capacity building. Gradually we are entering into a phase where we need debt to pay older debts and interests. Social welfare, capacity building, human development and investment in infrastructure are [going to be] some of the badly hit areas. We need to check our spending and require serious commitment to reforms.